Ever try talking to someone that didn't want to hear what you had to say? Wasn't paying attention to you? Isn't that frustrating? Not much point in talking to someone that isn't listenting, right? I think horses are like that with us. I think somewhere along the line they just give up trying to talk to us because we just aren't listening...
Basic Miss-communication
Horses are masters of subtlety, they are constantly communicating to us (too bad we so often miss the message). We all know the obvious ones, like the flattened ears and raised foot indicating you're about to get a nice new bruise if you don't move out of the line of fire :o) I don't mean those, I mean the 2mm shift in ears that differentiates between annoyance and intense concentration or the 3 inch difference in ears and shift in head angle that indicate a request for permission and not an act of aggression. This is going to be a tricky page as I'm not sure how best to explain the variances (degree of difference) because there are so many. It took one of my girls (Rina) getting smacked in the nose by someone I thought knew far more than I to get me to start issuing a brief Horse 101 lecture prior to any horse visits. This was one of the things that laid the foundation for my desire to share horses as they really are.
The Teacher's Tale
In a nutshell, Rina was punished for being polite. Sound ridiculous? Not really (happens all the time - just ask a horse :o) I had a "horse person" that I assumed (and yes, I lose points for that) was miles ahead of me in the area of horse expertise come for a visit. She taught riding, had competed and seemed (key word) to be very knowlegeable; in fairness she was - about many things (except, perhaps body language). We had walked out to the yard to see the girls, and were standing in the shade chatting a bit afterward. Rina approached our visitor, head lowered and ears laid back in a request for permission to enter her space (if you watch it enough, it doesn't really resemble aggression at all). Before I could say a word, the woman smacked Rina smartly on the nose and shooed her away stating no horse was going to bite her, honestly (the nerve).
What did I learn from this? Anyone that comes to visit gets "body language basics", and I don't care if you are a budding rocket scientist or not (that's immaterial :o) It's all about mutual R-E-S-P-E-C-T ~ you tell it Aretha! (ha).
It often strikes me, when I am watching a horse being schooled, how very little intelligence the trainer is displaying and how very good natured is the animal he is trying to teach. ~ M.F. McTaggart